reef12;128115 said:
Yes Tom maybe the water , maybe the filter, maybe the gravel as all different from your stuff and water.
After 100+ tanks with plants, I think I'd see some correlation if there was much to this claim.
Sure, 1% or less, heck, that's possible for many things that you'd never associate together.
Those are just my stats, but after helping folks for decades, you sort get a good idea.
I've yet to see such a case in person, I hear folks doing this every so often.
But only on the web.
Locals I've looked, but the CO2 was way over dosed in the 2 cases.
They had like, 4 fish in 75 gallon tank.........
They reduced and were okay.
Some though they had more CO2 than they did, but removed a light that changed their pH meter probe , I assume from stray current.
Many other things go on.
But if I do this on purpose on a well run tank, it have never once been good.
Now I've also done this inadvertently as well..the CO2 tank runs out of gas, the CO2 line popped off...........etc.
The results are not better growth in every case.
Now a CO2 reactor might be better at dissolving the CO2 at a lower rate say, than at a higher one.........and less mist and haze might help.
There's might other stuff going on, hard to say with little information except just one change mentioned.
No BS had the Rotala Wallichii about go away, the Pogostemon erectus, change it's leaves and boy does that plant smell bad, the Ludwigia Cuba change about 4 times, the Limnophila Aromatica change also.
When you say "changed", you mean better, worse, stinky dead plants, death? This does not sound better to me.
So maybe as my tank way different then yours could be. What do you think Tom?
What would be your routine on say ferts and light for a 125 and a 75?
Similar to my own 70 gal and 120 gallon, they are only off by 5 gallons
I run the ferts this way Macros' every other day 25 Ml of a solution of 1/8 cup to 16 ounces Distilled water, which is used on all of my solutions and kept in the fridge.
On the Micros' 25 Ml from a solution of 3 tablespoons in 10 ounces water.
On the other one 1 tablespoon and half , of potassium sulfate, mag sulfate, and mono potassium phosphate in 10 ounces of water.
Iron 1 and half teaspoons in 4 ounces water dosed everyday.
Any help? Seems I can't find the balance between all for both tanks , but can grow Ambulia like crazy and a few others, really fast
I will fight this battle until I win all the way, sort of like a Reef tank back in the 90s early 2000's
Jeff
Those real fast growing plants, try taking them out and seeing.
I bet they are just beating up on the others for CO2. Ferts are not likely the issue here.
One or a few aggressive weeds often show signs of a CO2 issue, they compete better than other plants for limited CO2 and lighting.
This occurs naturally in nature.